Court rejects pipeline developers’ request to overturn AT decision

The Fourth Circuit of the U.S. Court of Appeals declined to reconsider its December ruling that the U.S. Forest Service lacked authority to authorize the Atlantic Coast Pipeline from crossing the Appalachian Trail. The request came from pipeline developers led by Dominion and Duke Energy, who are pursuing construction of a unneeded natural gas pipeline that has hit opposition from citizens and courts at nearly every turn.

The Forest Service has never approved a new pipeline across the Appalachian Trail – but, under intense political pressure, it did.”

—D.J. Gerken, Senior Attorney

In its ruling, the court also found that the pipeline developers and the Forest Service ignored pursuing routes that would avoid the National Forest. The decision sends the Atlantic Coast Pipeline back to the drawing board.

“The Fourth Circuit’s decision, now final, confirmed that this pipeline has to play by the same rules as everybody else. The Forest Service has never approved a new pipeline across the Appalachian Trail – but, under intense political pressure, it did for Atlantic, while ignoring routes that would avoid the forest,” said Senior Attorney D.J. Gerken. “Atlantic could reroute, but instead it should scrap this boondoggle and stop running up a bill it wants to stick to customers.”

The court also ruled that the Forest Service approval fell short of federal requirements, noting that it failed to take the necessary look at environmental impacts of the project from risks of landslide and erosion and violated its own regulations. In its decision the court said, “A thorough review of the record leads to the necessary conclusion that the Forest Service abdicated its responsibility to preserve national forest resources.”

The pipeline, which would stretch from West Virginia into the Carolinas, is lacking seven permits necessary for construction. The problematic permits highlight the problems with rushing a destructive and unneeded project across some of the steepest terrain in our region, as well as one of our nation’s most iconic trails.

“The Fourth Circuit has once again made it clear what everyone but the corporate polluters behind the Atlantic Coast Pipeline already know: it is impossible to construct this fracked gas project without causing massive landslides and threatening the Appalachian Trail and our clean water. Any proposal to threaten our communities, our clean water, and our national parks and public lands simply cannot ever be permitted. It’s past time that the companies behind the disastrous Atlantic Coast Pipeline abandon this dirty and dangerous project once and for all,” said Sierra Club Senior Attorney Nathan Matthews.

More News

Virginia leaps forward on coal ash

Today, years of work by a host of dedicated citizens, conservation groups, and elected officials came to fruition, as Governor Ralph Northam sign...

It’s “Sunshine Week,” but SELC focus on public records is year-round

It’s Sunshine Week across our SELC region. And while we are enjoying the extra hour of evening sun gained by setting the clocks ahead, that’s not...

Clean Water Act proposal drastically cuts protections against pollution

SELC continues to battle a Trump administration proposal that would radically reduce the nation’s number of streams and wetlands protected by the...

Local residents, hunters, fishermen outraged by approval of $500M N.C. bridge

Local residents from the Currituck mainland and the nearby northern Outer Banks—along with hunters, fishermen, and wildlife enthusiasts from the...

Duke Energy overlooks clean energy opportunities in latest plan

A coalition of clean energy advocates filed expert analyses with North Carolina utility regulators today, finding that the Duke Energy’s long-ran...

Kingston coal ash disaster still reverberates 10 years later

Ten years ago, workers were several weeks into what would be the beginning of a multi-year cleanup of the largest toxic coal ash spill in U.S. hi...

More Stories