Endangered Nashville crayfish at risk of losing protections

The endangered Nashville crayfish is at risk of losing its protections under the Endangered Species Act. (© U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service)

Thirty-four years ago, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife service classified the Nashville crayfish as endangered. But now, the agency wants to remove the species from the Federal List of Endangered and Threatened Wildlife, permanently stripping all of the unique freshwater crustacean’s Endangered Species Act protections while potentially harming its habitat.

“The factors which led to its listing—an extremely limited geographic range suffering from water quality deterioration due to extensive and growing development—remain just as relevant today as three decades ago,” wrote Associate Attorney Chelsea Bowling in a letter to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service this year.

The Nashville crayfish is found only within the 27-mile natural refuge of Mill Creek and its tributaries on the edge of the most populous, and fastest-growing, city in the state of Tennessee.

Continues Bowling in her letter, “It was initially listed as endangered because of a basic fact of its existence: it is a little animal, living in one little watershed, right next to a very big city.”

It was initially listed as endangered because of a basic fact of its existence: it is a little animal, living in one little watershed, right next to a very big city.”

—Chelsea Bowling, Associate Attorney

The Nashville crayfish’s range is highly restricted. Because it has so little room for retreat, any threats to that range are disproportionately detrimental to the species’ chance of survival.

“If anything, threats to the species are increasing,” says Nashville Office Director Amanda Garcia. She notes increasing development of the city’s metro area and a climate change-caused increase in extreme weather events that could further damage the species’ habitat, such as more frequent and severe droughts and floods.

Likewise, the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service’s attempt to remove protections for the crayfish under the Endangered Species Act could jeopardize not only the crustacean, but the entire area surrounding Mill Creek, which flows into the Cumberland River.

“For the past three decades, this special Nashville place has been protected from irresponsible development in part due to protections for the crayfish, protections that would be removed under this proposed delisting,” reiterates Garcia.

To justify delisting a species, the Service generally shows two things: First, the species’ population must have increased to, or at least stabilized at, a size where the threat of a catastrophic event—such as a toxic spill—is reasonably mitigated. And second, sufficient mechanisms in place, or enough overall habitat improvement, to ensure that removing the species from the Endangered Species Act’s protection wouldn’t immediately drive the species back to the brink of extinction.

The Service has not met its burden with respect to either showing.

It is currently accepting comments on its proposal to delist the Nashville crayfish until October 23, and will hold a virtual public hearing on October 8. Submit a public comment here.
If you would like to make a public comment at the virtual hearing, register here.

Want more SELC Stories? Get our monthly enewsletter featuring highlights from across the South.

More News

New season of Broken Ground focuses on women fighting for environmental justice

In celebration of Earth Day, SELC launched the latest season of its podcast, Broken Ground, talking with women in the South who are on the frontl...

Memphis-area member of Congress leads letter asking Biden to re-evaluate Byhalia permit

U.S. Rep. Steve Cohen, who represents Memphis, led an effort with U.S. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez to send a letter from 28 members of Congress...

South must play a key role in addressing climate change, biodiversity crises

President Joe Biden has taken early steps to show how seriously he is taking the threat posed by climate change — from rejoining the Paris Agreem...

Brenda Mallory confirmed as Chair of White House Council on Environmental Quality

Brenda Mallory, SELC’s director of regulatory policy, has been confirmed by the United States Senate to lead the White House Council on Environme...

Final hearing on NEPA changes headed to court this month

SELC is preparing for a federal showdown on April 21 to determine the fate of the Trump administration’s gutting of the National Environmental Po...

How we’re working to ensure a safer Cape Fear River basin for N.C. communities

An agreement by state regulators with the City of Greensboro allows increased discharges of cancer-causing 1,4-dioxane into the drinking water so...

More Stories